Judaism: You’re doing it wrong!

April 13th, 2011  |  by  |  Published in Uncategorized  |  3 Comments

My brother and his wife live in St. Paul, Minnesota, with their two daughters (which I suppose if Nathan is to have is way, makes them my nieces). Neither one of us is a mutli-millionaire (yet), so we don’t often have the time and the money to get together, but we both try to make family vacations and the holidays a priority.

Passover is probably the only significant religious event that we do every year, and even that is far from devout (our Seder: “The history of Judaism in nine words: they tried to kill us. We won. Let’s eat”). But it is an important thing, a strong connection to our past, and a way to show our children why we care about each other.

Unfortunately, my brother wasn’t able to get time off from work during Passover this year, and it seemed as if it wouldn’t be possible for all of us to get together. He called about a week ago, however, to tell me that he really wanted us to have a seder, even if it meant doing things a tad on the unconventional side.

Passover this year begins this coming Monday. My brother and his family will arrive in NYC on Saturday and leave early Monday morning. We’re going to hold a seder, then, on Sunday night, and well, just pretend that we got the dates right.

What does this mean? I don’t know. Not much, really. We’re all together, we’re going to eat all the same food, say all the same prayer(s), open the door for Elijah as directed–only a day early. I’m aware that the holiday falls on the day that it does for a reason (although I’m not entirely sure what that reason is–do we know the exact calendar date of the Exodus? Really?). But I choose having my loved ones with me over, shall we say, cold and clinical religious accuracy.

And I’m not drinking kosher wine.

I was reminded of all of this today when my brother sent me an article on NPR’s website: “‘Our “Haggadah’: A Guide For Interfaith Families,” which is apparently about Cokie Robert’s take on the faith of of our fathers.

That I should be getting a lesson in how to do the Jew thing from Cokie Roberts is cause for a certain amount of alarm, to be sure. But she did say one thing that stuck with me, and perhaps gives me an excuse to hold me seder whenever I damn well choose (how about December?):

Hosting her first Passover Seder in 1969 was an intimidating experience, Cokie says. “It’s hard enough just to have a dinner party, much less to have one where you have strange foods and the table looks different from any other night.”

Cokie had brought a Haggadah — the Jewish text that guides the Seder — from a local synagogue to direct the evening’s rituals, but quickly found there were many critics in the room. “I had a lot of friends who felt free to comment,” she says. ” ‘Oh, you left out this part’ … ‘Wait a minute, you shouldn’t have put that part in,’ and all that.” The next year, she decided it was time to create a uniquely Roberts Haggadah.


  1. Moshe Sharon says:

    April 13th, 2011at 1:23 pm(#)

    Tornadoes, flooding, forest fires, runaway inflation, massive foreclosures, food shortages, record unemployment and gay marriage; aside from the fact that we are at war for our very survival against unseen enemies who are plotting who knows what. We have weather woes, fiscal firestorms and a public character plunging into moral chaos, while we worry about terrorists being among the thousands of illegal aliens pouring across the Mexican border every day; perhaps this is the perfect storm. America, the society that G-d has blessed with more power and wealth than the world has ever known, is facing enormous challenges on all fronts. Yet most of us seem to be living our lives still intact, thank G-d, so we need to look at all these unfortunate circumstances as a series of warnings. If you would ask what these warnings are about, take your pick. We have a social order that has clear distinctions between moral and legal. Immorality can be legal and the police can arrest people for doing the right thing. That is very different from living a Torah life where morality is the law.

  2. dadwagon says:

    April 13th, 2011at 1:28 pm(#)

    Lions, tigers, and bears, oy vey! –theodore.

  3. Matt says:

    April 15th, 2011at 5:22 am(#)

    Torah, schmorah.

Leave a Response


Recent Comments

  • Dee: As one of the impressed moms there last night, and also because my kid ate 3 bowls of that bolognese, thanks for...
  • Drew Wallner via Facebook: I’m totally making this when we get back from holiday travel, I even just got a...
  • Matt: Whoops! Just put that back in. The recipe editor has been fired.
  • Ed Lilly: Looks great – thanks for posting! One question – you did not specify putting the meat back into...
  • Maks: I’m against baby yoga for sure, but want to say something regarding that author is a little wild about...

DadWagon Reads!